Cardgames Social
Pauper deep dive9 min readUpdated: June 2026

Pauper Rules, Legality & the Ban Timeline

The part players actually search for: exactly which printings make a card legal, the edge cases that trip people up, and an annotated history of every ban since tabletop support arrived.

Legality edge casesThe ban timeline
Legality test
Ever common
Source of truth
Gatherer
Tabletop since
June 2019
In this guide
01What “printed at common” really means02The annotated ban timeline03FAQ04Sources & credits
01

Legality

What “printed at common” really means

The rule is one sentence; the edge cases are where the questions live.

A card is Pauper-legal if any printing of it is recorded at common rarity on Gatherer — any set, any year, paper or digital. Rarity shifts both ways are common across Magic’s history, so the format’s real card pool is bigger and stranger than the current set’s common sheet.

CaseLegal?Why
Downshifted in a Masters setYesAny common printing in any set counts — Masters downshifts are how staples enter the format
MTGO-only common, never paperYesDigital sets count since the June 2019 unification
Common in a non-tournament productCheck GathererLegality follows the rarity recorded on Gatherer for that printing
Uncommon everywhere, rare nowhereNoUncommon is not common — Pauper Commander is the format that wants these
On the culturally-offensive global ban listNoWotC’s game-wide removals apply on top of the format ban list
The legality edge cases players actually search for.

Before June 2019, the rule was different

Pauper began as an MTGO format, and legality originally meant “common on Magic Online.” The 2019 tabletop announcement unified it to “common in any set” — if you read pre-2019 articles, their legality claims may be stale.

02

The record

The annotated ban timeline

Every era of the ban list since official tabletop support, and why each wave happened.

2019 → today

  1. 12019 — tabletop support arrives with a unified ban list; the early list carries over MTGO-era bans targeting degenerate combo (storm pieces, Cloudpost ramp).
  2. 22019–2021 — the slow-process era: Arcum’s Astrolabe (2019 ban) warps the format for months first; Fall From Favor (2021) dominates from a single Commander Legends downshift; Chatterstorm (2021) gets summer-storm bans. The lag here is what motivates the panel.
  3. 3January 2022 — the Pauper Format Panel forms; cadence changes from reactive and slow to communicative and fast.
  4. 42022–2023 — panel-era maintenance bans target the Initiative package (Monarch/Initiative free-value engines from Commander-product downshifts) and affinity enablers.
  5. 5June 6, 2024 — the affinity reckoning: Cranial Plating and All That Glitters banned, and Cranial Ram banned preemptively before Modern Horizons 3 even released — a first for the format.
  6. 6March 31, 2025 — the panel tries its first trial unban: High Tide returns to the format on probation.
  7. 7November 2025 — the trial ends the way the deck previews suggested: High Tide goes back on the list after warping the metagame around big-mana combo.
  8. 82026 — the panel’s cadence continues; check the official B&R history for the latest actions before relying on any list you read.

Read the list as a philosophy document: at common rarity there are few answers to board floods, free spells, and lock pieces, so bans target consistency engines and mana cheats rather than fair-but-strong threats. If a card generates repeatable advantage for free at common, its clock is ticking.

FAQ

Common questions

How do I check if a specific card is Pauper-legal?
Look it up on Gatherer or Scryfall and check whether any printing is common — Scryfall’s “legal: pauper” indicator does the work for you. Then confirm it is not on the current ban list.
Why was Cranial Ram banned before it was even released?
The panel judged its affinity math — a Modern Horizons 3 downshift — to be format-warping on arrival, and banned it preemptively rather than letting it dominate first. It was the first preemptive ban in Pauper’s history.
Do Commander-product downshifts really end up in Pauper?
Yes, and they have caused some of the format’s biggest problems — Fall From Favor and the Initiative cards entered Pauper through Commander-product printings at common. Any common printing counts, whatever the product.

Sources & credits

The creators who documented these formats

Pack Wars is community-built. These are the writers, wikis, and Wizards of the Coast references that originated and documented the rules summarized here.

  1. 40Announcing the Pauper Format PanelWizards of the Coast — Gavin VerheyJan 10, 2022: the panel’s founding, membership, and mandate.
  2. 41PauperMTG WikiFormat rules, MTGO origins, and the 2019 tabletop unification.
  3. 42Pauper Format PanelMTG WikiPanel membership, process, and ban history.
  4. 44Pauper Panel Happy With State Of The FormatStar City GamesPanel-era metagame and ban-list coverage.

Keep going

Related guides and tools

Pauper overview

The hub: the one rule, the MTGO origins, and the Format Panel.

Open

The Pauper metagame

The archetype pillars the ban list is balanced around.

Open

The history of Commander

The contrasting governance story: full independence, crisis, and handover.

Open